We’ve all heard the contemporary praise song that says “I will” more than a few times. Phrases like “I will celebrate,” “I will sing to God,” “I will praise God,” are sung and repeated many times in the same song. Here are James Montgomery Boice’s comments on such a song:
The chorus seems to be praising God – it claims to be praising him – but that is the one thing it does not actually do. As [Marva] Dawn points out, ‘The verbs say ‘I will,’ but in this song I don’t, because although God is mentioned as the recipient of my praise and signing, the song never says a single thing about or to God.
What is the song about then? If we look at it carefully, the answer is clear. With all the repeats, ‘I’ is the subject twenty-eight times. Not God, but ‘I’ myself, And not even myself along with other members of the covenant community, just ‘I’. ‘With that kind of focus,’ says Dawn, ‘we might suppose that all the “hallelujahs” are praising how good I am…at celebrating and singing.’ What is this but narcissism, an absorption with ourselves which is only a pitiful, sad characteristic of our culture? If we are self-absorbed in our worship services, as we seem to be, it can only mean that we are worldly in our worship, and not spiritual as we ignorantly suppose.
The praise songs of the Psalter do not fall into this trap, which is one reason why they are such good models for our worship and why they should be used in worship more often than they are. Think of just the last five psalms, as an example. They are a kind of praise climax to the Psalter, showing us what it means to praise God….
Covenant Presbyterian Church (OPC)